You Want Another Index? Here We Go with INNOVATION!

By Renard Teipelke

There is probably no index missing in the profession (and obsession) of ranking cities. One index that was recently mentioned in the UN-Habitat State of the World Cities Report 2012/2013 is the Innovation Cities Index.

2thinknow, the company behind this index, advertises it as the “world’s largest city classification and ranking with 331 benchmark cities classified”. Cities are ranked globally and per region and are classified as “nexus”, “hub”, “node”, “influencer”, or “upstart” – basically ascribing to cities a higher to lower degree of importance/relevance with regard to ‘innovation’; with “nexus” cities (such as Boston, Vienna, Munich, Copenhagen, Hong Kong, or Seoul) at the top as being the crucial centers for multiple social and economic innovation sectors, and “upstart” cities (such as Jakarta, Kolkata, Johannesburg, Karachi, Manama, or Lima) at the bottom as having potentially some innovative sectors in the future.

1 Boston United States 1 NEXUS
2 San Francisco Bay Area United States 1 NEXUS
3 Paris France 1 NEXUS
4 New York United States 1 NEXUS
5 Vienna Austria 1 NEXUS
6 Amsterdam Netherlands 1 NEXUS
7 Munich Germany 1 NEXUS
8 Lyon France 1 NEXUS
9 Copenhagen Denmark 1 NEXUS
10 Toronto Canada 1 NEXUS
11 London United Kingdom 1 NEXUS
12 Frankfurt Germany 1 NEXUS
13 Hamburg Germany 1 NEXUS
14 Berlin Germany 1 NEXUS
15 Hong Kong Hong Kong 1 NEXUS
16 Milan Italy 1 NEXUS
17 Melbourne Australia 1 NEXUS
18 Stuttgart Germany 1 NEXUS
19 Barcelona Spain 1 NEXUS
20 Sydney Australia 1 NEXUS
21 Stockholm Sweden 1 NEXUS
22 Tokyo Japan 1 NEXUS
23 Rome Italy 1 NEXUS
24 Shanghai China 1 NEXUS
25 Seattle United States 1 NEXUS
26 Singapore Singapore 1 NEXUS
27 Strasbourg France 1 NEXUS
28 Seoul Korea, South 1 NEXUS
29 Los Angeles United States 1 NEXUS
30 Kyoto Japan 1 NEXUS

Place 1 to 30 in the global innovation cities ranking 2011

I do not want to go into the methodological details of the index, but 2thinknow has definitely put effort into designing what they call the “most comprehensive city ranking and scoring”. Besides general characteristics for cities (demographics, geography, health, wealth, etc.), the cities are analyzed based on benchmarking indicators that are cross-checked with qualitative and quantitative data. Eventually the data is compared to global trends and a “zeitgeist (analyst confidence) factor” is added, with cultural assets, human infrastructure, and networked markets factors included. Sounds sophisticated and I do not feel enough qualified to judge about the scientific rigor of the index.

A look at the tables reveal a somewhat different ranking of cities in comparison to other rankings (such as for GDP, creativity, or liveability). For some cities, one can find this index as a ‘proof’ that they will not lose ground in competition with so called global cities (this might be especially true for European cities). For other cities, one can understand with the help of this index, why they have been so ‘successful’ in the past (and probably also in the future) even though they are not necessarily liveable or world-famous (such as Manchester, Marseille, Minneapolis-St. Paul, Karlsruhe, Dortmund, or Reims).

Infomodel by Jess Hadden: How Innovative Cities are formed and function (adapted from Richard Florida’s 2005 book Cities and the Creative Class)

So what do we do with the Innovation Index now? Add it to our long list of fancy indices and rankings? Be happy that our home town finally showed up in the top 100? Ask what ‘innovation’ means, how it can be differentiated from creativity, economic progress, and alternativeness? Probably no one would doubt that ‘innovation’ is important to a city’s vitality and prosperous future. The question then would be: How can cities (i.e. public, private, and civil-society actors) produce, support, and trigger innovation? Answers to this question can be purchased as innovation services from 2thinknow 😉

This entry was posted in research and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to You Want Another Index? Here We Go with INNOVATION!

  1. Pingback: Measure It, Compare It, Monitor It | Places.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s